McAllen Insurance Bad Faith Lawyer

Home  /  McAllen Insurance Bad Faith Lawyer
McAllen insurance bad faith lawyer Abraham Peña

Insurance Bad Faith Attorney in McAllen, TX

You paid your premiums for years. When you finally needed the policy after a wreck, the company asked for the same documents three times, changed adjusters twice and then sent a letter denying the claim in language you could not follow. Or it paid a fraction of what the medical bills actually cost and told you the file was closed.

An insurance policy is a contract, and Texas law adds duties on top of it. Your insurer is required to handle claims promptly, pay what it owes on time and deal with you fairly. When it does not, you may be entitled to more than the original claim.

Attorney Abraham Peña has roots in the Rio Grande Valley and represents policyholders in English and Spanish. Bring us the policy and the denial letter, and let us read them first.

Don’t Wait Protect Your Rights Now

Auto Insurance Disputes in the Rio Grande Valley

Valley families deal with insurers after car wrecks and the injuries that follow. In personal injury cases, we look at auto insurance disputes involving:

  • Uninsured and underinsured motorist claims
  • Personal Injury Protection (PIP) and medical payments coverage
  • Denied or delayed injury claims under your own auto policy
  • Settlement demands to an at-fault driver’s insurer within policy limits
  • Other auto insurance disputes that arise from an injury claim

What to Do When Your Insurer Delays or Denies Your Claim

  • Ask for the denial or the reason for delay in writing.
  • Get a complete copy of your policy, including the declarations page and endorsements.
  • Keep a log. Note every call, name, date and promise.
  • Send documents in a way you can prove, such as email or certified mail.
  • Do not cash a check marked as full and final payment before getting advice.
  • Keep your medical bills and records, along with photos and repair estimates for your vehicle.

Who Can Be Held Responsible?

  • Your insurance company.
  • An adjuster or adjusting firm, in some cases.
  • An insurance agent who misrepresented what the policy covered.

A claim against the other driver’s insurer works differently. In Texas an injured person generally cannot sue someone else’s insurer for bad faith. That insurer does owe its own customer a duty to accept a reasonable settlement demand within policy limits, and a properly prepared demand that the insurer unreasonably rejects may make the company answerable for a judgment above those limits. We prepare demands with that rule in mind.

What Does Texas Law Require of Your Insurer?

For most claims, the Texas Insurance Code sets a schedule:

  • Within 15 days of notice, the insurer must acknowledge the claim, begin investigating and ask for what it reasonably believes it needs.
  • Within 15 business days of receiving what it asked for, it must accept or reject the claim in writing and give the reasons for any rejection. If it needs more time, it must say why within that period and then decide within 45 more days.
  • Within five business days of accepting, it generally must pay.

An insurer that is liable on a claim and does not follow these rules can owe interest of 18 percent a year plus attorney’s fees. In uninsured and underinsured motorist claims, however, the insurer generally does not have to pay until the other driver’s fault and the amount of damages are established, so these deadlines and penalties often apply differently in those cases.

The Code also prohibits unfair practices, including:

  • Misrepresenting what the policy says
  • Refusing to pay without a reasonable investigation
  • Failing to make a good-faith effort at a fair settlement when liability is reasonably clear
  • Failing to promptly explain a denial

An insurer that does these things knowingly may be ordered to pay up to three times the actual damages.

Texas courts also recognize a common-law duty of good faith and fair dealing that an insurer owes its own policyholder. An insurer may breach that duty when it denies or delays payment after its liability has become reasonably clear. A legitimate dispute over coverage or value, by itself, is generally not bad faith.

What You Can Recover in a Bad Faith Case

  • The policy benefits that should have been paid
  • Penalty interest for late payment
  • Attorney’s fees
  • Other losses caused by the denial, and mental anguish in some cases
  • Up to three times actual damages for knowing violations

How Long Do You Have to File, and What Deadlines Apply?

Claims for unfair insurance practices under the Insurance Code generally must be filed within two years from the date the practice occurred or the date you discovered, or reasonably should have discovered, it. Common-law bad faith claims also generally have a two-year limit. A claim for breach of the policy is generally subject to a four-year limit, though some policies shorten it; Texas law generally does not allow a policy to shorten it to less than two years. Before suing under the Insurance Code, written notice to the insurer is usually required at least 61 days before the suit is filed, unless the deadline to sue is about to run.

In uninsured and underinsured motorist cases, the bad faith claim usually waits until the underlying car wreck case establishes fault and damages. The order matters, and so does preserving both claims from the start.

FAQs

My insurer made a low offer. Is that bad faith?

Not always. Insurers may dispute the value of a claim in good faith. A low offer with no real investigation or explanation behind it is a different matter.

The other driver’s insurance company is ignoring me. Can I sue it for bad faith?

Generally not directly. Your claim is against the driver, and the insurer’s duty runs to its own customer. A formal demand within policy limits is often what gets that insurer to take the claim seriously.

My insurer keeps asking for the same documents. What can I do?

Keep a written record of what you sent and when. An insurer may ask for more information when it is reasonably needed, but Texas law sets deadlines for an insurer to acknowledge, investigate and decide a claim, and missed deadlines can matter later.

How much does it cost to hire an insurance bad faith lawyer?

Nothing up front. We work on a contingency fee and are paid only if we recover money for you.

Abraham Pena Image

contact Attorney Abraham Peña

Talk to a McAllen Insurance Bad Faith Lawyer Today

The insurance company handles claims every day. You should not have to handle yours alone. Call The Law Office of Abraham Peña, PLLC at (737) 999-3335 or use our contact page for a free, confidential consultation. There is no fee unless we win. Our office is at 813 N Main St., Suite 404, McAllen, by appointment. Hablamos español. Esta página también está disponible en español: abogado de mala fe de aseguradoras en McAllen.

No Fees Unless You Win

You pay nothing upfront. Our fee is only collected
if we secure compensation for you.

Location

813 N Main St. Suite 404
McAllen TX, 78501

By Appointment Only

Contact (737) 999-3335

Get In Touch

Fields marked with an * are required

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
*
Agreement

© Copyright 2026 Attorney Abraham Peña. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer | Site Map | Privacy Policy.

*Images are obtained under license from Canva and other third-party stock image providers, with attribution included where required.